One
of the first posts for this blog is one of the most important questions that
one should ask themselves when they are picking out a martial art to
study. If someone has no experience in
martial arts, which one should they study? I have wracked my brain for an appropriate
answer and with those who have studied martial arts for a number of years, that
does not seem so important. In
conversation with a few instructors, I have found that the instructor will want
the student to study their martial art.
A karateka will say “Study karate!”
A judoka will say “Judo is the way to go!” A aikido master will say “Try aikido!” But if you’re a new person who is fascinated
with the martial way, just like a worn forest, there are many paths to travel
on.
Roughly three days after the post, I
found an article on my Facebook page that addressed which martial arts are good
for women. At first, I thought of this
as being particularly sexist (I mean, come on!
In every martial art I’ve studied, there have been women in the class
who trained just as hard and advanced just as far as their male counterparts). Yet, as I read the article, I found their
recommendations interesting. Arts such
as kickboxing, aikido, and tae kwon do were among the top choices. I reposted the article. Since there are a lot of martial artists and
fitness experts on my Facebook account, I knew I would get a response.
A few emails in my inbox came from
martial artists who told me that the rationale made sense, but they did not
agree with some of the choices. Most
replied with “Study [insert their martial art]!
I have done [insert their martial art] for years and [insert their martial
art] has helped me so much. So I
wholeheartedly support anyone who is interested in [insert their martial art].” At the end of the day, I was excited to begin
training in seven different martial arts.
However, the point wasn’t really addressed.
Ultimately, I would agree with the
experts, it’s not about the martial art because anyone (of any size, body type,
weight, etc.) can begin training in any form of martial art. Unfortunately, this did not answer the reader’s
question. One can go with height and by
type. I am a short, endomorph (stocky
and easy to gain weight). As such, judo
seemed to be the natural martial art for me.
A lot of my fellow judoka are taller and lighter than I am; since many
of the throws require a certain amount of squatting or quasi-wrestling type of moves
that seems to be the natural choice for me.
I love judo, but I had to “learn” to love it. The falls I was taking were quite brutal and
if one doesn’t learn how to take a fall, then they will grow tired of the art
very quickly.
With sports that require lots of
kicking, being light on one’s feet is a very good thing. Karate or tae kwon do may seem to be good for
those who are tall and slender (perhaps ectomorphs). Those who have a background in ballet, or are
naturally graceful, may enjoy arts such as tai chi and aikido. However, this does not mean that a short
person will love judo or a former ballet person will love tai chi. I think kempo, tai chi, and aikido may be
great for women, but that does not mean that every woman will love these arts
(or others will hate them). The tallest
judoka in my class throws me around the mat every single time we do randori (light sparring).
Some may pick a martial art for
practical reasons. If a person wants to
compete in an MMA competition, then they may study jujitsu or judo. Some may pick tai chi to work on graceful
steps and work their joints. Different
martial arts have a different do
(way). Martial artists may agree that
studying karate will set you on a different path than studying jeet kune
do. However, both will train one to be
more focused than one was before starting the journey. I suppose a question would be: what do you
want to get out of the martial art? If
it is to compete in a MMA tournament, then some arts would be more beneficial
than others. I have heard tai chi called
a “dirty martial art”. As a tai chi
student, the martial art was not created with “rules” in mind. What would be illegal in a Mixed Martial Arts
competition is just good sense when fighting a street fight. So if I was to compete in an MMA bout, I may
be disqualified.
So before you look for a
dojo/school/etc., ask yourself the following questions:
1. Why study the martial arts? What do I hope to gain from it?
2. How can I make it a part of my schedule? Can I blend it into my daily lifestyle?
3. What do I want to do with it? Am I interested in competing, protecting
myself and my family, or being a teacher of it (or something else)?
4. How do I see it benefiting me?
Once
you’ve carefully thought this through, go to a local school/dojo and talk to
the instructors. One thing I know about
black belts is that they LOVE to talk about their martial art. They can take you through all of the
strengths and weaknesses (but mostly strengths) of their art. They are open to talking about other arts, as
well. If you give any martial artist an
excuse to talk about what they enjoy studying, you’re in for an earful.
Also, do your homework. Typing the martial art into a search engine
online will open your eyes to a ton of websites devoted to practicing the art
in question. I would recommend going to
YouTube to watch videos of the martial art.
Again, most of these videos may be created by practitioners and fans of
the art. Just keep in mind that many of
these practitioners are experts themselves so just because you may see them
flipping and breaking bricks on video does not mean that you will be expected
to do so upon your first foray into the art.
I started judo about a year and a half ago, and the first two or three
weeks were spent focusing on low falls and rolls. Enjoy your experience in the dojo/school and
keep your mind open!
[Gassho!]